Welcome to Mister Pizza
At Mister Pizza, we blend tradition and innovation, creating an inviting space for pizza lovers in Amherst, NY. Our passion for quality is reflected in our diverse menu, featuring not only classic pizzas but also mouth-watering chicken wings and unique subs like the Mini Chicken Parmesan. Customers rave about our crispy crusts and generous toppings, delivering satisfaction with every bite. Whether you choose to dine in our outdoor seating, place a quick takeout order, or enjoy delivery, our friendly service ensures an excellent experience. Join us at Mister Pizza, where every meal feels like home, and be part of our flourishing pizza community!
-
614 Grover Cleveland Hwy Amherst, NY 14226 United States Hotline: (716) 835-6500
Welcome to the vibrant world of Mister Pizza, where culinary passion meets the art of pizza making! Nestled in the heart of Amherst, NY, at 614 Grover Cleveland Hwy, Mister Pizza is a charming eatery offering a delightful array of pizzas and chicken wings that caters to both the takeout enthusiast and the dine-in seeker.
This fantastic establishment doesn’t just serve food; it aims to create an experience. A wide range of utilities ensures your visit is comfortable and enjoyable, including:
- Delivery and Takeout options
- Heated and Covered Outdoor Seating
- Private Dining and Catering
- Live TV and Free Wi-Fi
- Alcohol services and Drive-Thru convenience
Mister Pizza has captured the hearts of many, as evidenced by glowing customer reviews. “One of the best vegan pizzas I've ever had!” raves Ruth S., noting that her family also enjoyed the classic cheese, pepperoni, and meatball varieties. This commitment to quality extends to their mini and whole subs, baked to perfection with gooey mozzarella cheese and hearty fillings, making for an unforgettable experience.
Among the menu highlights, the Mini Chicken Parmesan Sub and the whole Royal Pizza stand out as crowd favorites. The Royal Pizza, loaded with cheese and a generous helping of meat, can make any pizza lover swoon. Patrick O. mentions, “The menu has a lot of choices for pizzas and subs. Glad to see them finally open!” This excitement is palpable throughout the community, especially after the previous establishment left a gap that Mister Pizza has filled with gusto.
Now, let’s talk crust. Emily L. shares a love for their crispy, greasy, and chewy outer edge that provides the perfect base for an abundant topping of cheese and pepperoni. The kids loved their meals, and it’s clear that Mister Pizza has managed to create family-friendly flavors that cater to even the pickiest of eaters.
With the ability to place orders ahead of time or simply pop in for a slice, Mister Pizza combines convenience with quality. Those who visit will find friendly service waiting, eager to share their love of pizza with anyone who walks through the door.
If you’re in the area, don’t miss an opportunity to indulge in what Mister Pizza has to offer. Whether you're craving a classic slice or ready to dive into a delicious sub, this restaurant stands ready to satisfy your every pizza desire.
For more information or to place an order, call (716) 835-6500. Experience the new sensation that is Mister Pizza, where great food and warm service come together in delicious harmony.
One of the best vegan pizzas I've ever had! Family also loved the sheet cheese, pepperoni and meatball pizza.
White pizza is my go to! Perfect amount of olive oil, cheese, and garlic. Outstanding
Me and my two friends had a cheese, pep and mushroom za from mister pizza.so freakin good. Perfect pizza. Please give them your biz !! Unfortunately, this is my last review. I have had no impact on yelp. I love all of your looks, but obviously I've had no effect. So, I say goodbye thanks to everyone.
Update- needed a quick fix on my way home so I looked them up online and placed a small order. Door dash pick up? Whatever. Personal pizza and 5 wings. Ready before quoted time, hot and fresh when I got home. Still no complaints from me. Looks like they have a nice little eat in area I don't remember seeing that before.
Psyched this place is finally open and was not disappointed with our first order! Called to order pick up - grateful for this Yelp page and the previous reviews cause I couldn't find a number on Google. Ordered an easy half cheese, half pepperoni large pizza to enjoy with the kids while watching the premier league (come on red men!). They told me 35 minutes which is exactly when I showed up, and it was ready to go. The guy at the counter was real nice and friendly - took my card and gave me the pizza. Off I went! My fave part of pizza has always been the crust and this crispy, greasy, chewy crust hit the spot. As others have mentioned, it was not lacking on toppings at all - loads of cheese and pepperoni on one side. In fact, I took some off which my husband was happy to take off my hands. My 6-year-old and 22-month-old also gave it a big thumbs up. Nice to have a new spot in our neighborhood that we love!
Got the Royal pizza. it was good. Lots of cheese, good amount of meat. Menu has a lot of choices for pizzas and subs. Glad to see them finally open as this location has had a pizza place for decades and after Leonardis closed there was a lot of drama and delays.
I'm so happy they are FINALLY open! I was so excited to try their pizza tonight. This is a place where you can order ahead by phone, or order to go from the counter. I opted for a slice to go, and got a slice of cheese pizza since that's all they had at the time. There's no dine-in/seating yet. The service was quick and friendly. I'd love to come here again to try one of their subs or calzones.